In recent times there has been a massive upsurge in the alternative
health scene which has presented many dilemmas for Christians who would like to
explore alternative health options but at the same time are wanting to avoid
anything mixed up with false religions. I’d like to divulge some of my own
findings as I have looked into these questions and hopefully provide a bit of
guidance to this minefield.
Homeopathy
I’ll begin with Homeopathy because clarifying what this is
will also help to bring clarity in our discussion later.
Christians need to have their definitions clear regarding
the various ‘path-ies’, and this one in particular must not be mistaken for
‘alternative herbal health’. It is alternative herbal health but there is a
whole lot more to it than that.
Homeopathy is simply psychic healing - one of the many
strands of eastern New Age occultism. The father of homeopathic ‘medicine’ is Samuel
Hahnemann. He wrote the ‘Bible’ on Homeopathy called the Organon of Medicine. Both the author and his ‘Bible’ are regarded
by Homeopathic practitioners as divinely inspired. Although homeopathy uses medical
sounding language, it is only pseudo-science that is masking what is
essentially a faith-based belief system.
For a Christian to consult with a homeopath is to do what is
forbidden in Leviticus 19:31, "Do not turn to mediums or seek out
spiritists, for you will be defiled by them."
The natural question which springs from this then is – ‘Is
it sinful to use homeopathic remedies?’
Homeopathic remedies
This question is reminiscent of the question Paul addressed
in his letter to the Corinthians regarding meat that had been sacrificed to
idols. There is nothing wrong with meat per se, but for those that offer it up
to idols it takes on a spiritual significance. In the same way, there may be
nothing evil with homeopathic remedies per se, yet for homeopathic
practitioners it does take on a mystical healing quality.
Paul’s advice on this to the Corinthians was to follow your
own conscience. If you cannot take the meat (or in this case the homeopathic
medicine) in faith, do not partake in it.
On a less spiritual note, you will find that homeopathic
‘remedies’ are based upon ridiculous pseudo-scientific beliefs which render
their potions to be nothing more than expensive water.
Homeopathic remedies operate on the patently unscientific
principle that the more you dilute the
remedy, the more potent it becomes. Dilution is a key part of the
homeopathic preparation. The most commonly used ratio for dilution is 1:1060!
So whatever healing properties the remedy may have had before the preparation,
after this kind of dilution it is nothing more than ‘holy water’.
Homeopathic language
It is important to highlight commonly used language in
homeopathy because it has broader usage in the alternative health scene and the
language usage should alert Christians to a faith-based system that is not
reliant upon the Holy Spirt but on other spirits instead.
The New Age eastern religions have as a common theme their
belief that there is a ‘cosmic energy’ which permeates all of creation. This
cosmic energy is a god-like force in nature. It is sometimes referred to as the
‘vital force’ or ‘vital principle’. At other times it is referred to as
‘vibrations’ or ‘good energy’.
According to this thinking, when a person is ill it is
because there is something disordered in their ‘energy field’. The healing
property in the remedy is therefore more to do with the ‘energy field’ of the
concoction than any healing properties in the ingredients themselves.
Whenever the packaging of a particular remedy refers to
healing ‘mind, body and soul’ or anything to do with your spirit, we Christians
need to be alerted to fact that there is a spiritual dynamic being invoked.
Only the Holy Spirit can bring healing to the mind, body and soul.
Essential oils
What distinguishes essential oils from homeopathic remedies
is the fact that they are not diluted into nothingness in the way that I
described earlier. The oil is prepared in such a way that it retains the concentrated
ingredients of the plant which it was taken from.
This opens up the possibility that if the plant has
medicinal properties, and those medicinal properties have been concentrated in
the oil, the oil might have medicinal value if it is applied correctly.
Having said that, there is a lot for a Christian to consider
when using essential oils. The world of ‘alternative health-care’ very quickly
gets caught up into the realm of Eastern religious thought and practice and so
we need to have our wits about us. Here are some important considerations:
Pseudo-science +
religious beliefs
As Christians we believe that God has placed good things in
creation that can be beneficial for our health. Therefore, we can study nature
in order to discover things that will help us. All medicine comes from
ingredients found in creation that have health benefits.
Unfortunately, many alternative health remedies are founded
upon the unbiblical premise that ingredients from creation have divine,
mystical powers to heal because God is in
everything. Certain natural elements are then thought to have mystical
healing properties because of their ‘good energy’ without any basis in
scientific principle.
You may have noticed certain essential oils are reported to
heal everything from anxiety to asthma. This is because the New Age religion
believes that the Cosmic Energy affects every area of your life, including
relational, financial and physical wellbeing. ‘Good energies’ in certain natural ingredients
can therefore ‘heal’ all manner of unrelated aspects of life.
In much of the language found on packaging, there is a
curious mix of Eastern religious beliefs and scientific-sounding language. Here
is an example regarding oils and crystals:
“Crystals also give off energy- but because of their
crystalline structure, their energy is constant -not changing like ours.
Because of this, they can help us rebalance our own energies.”
If/when we use natural remedies we must not be influenced
regarding how we think about the healing properties found in plants. God has
given us good gifts, including plants with medicinal benefits, but nature is
not divine nor does nature have mystical healing energies.
Lack of
accountability
In the US, essential oils are not allowed to advertise
themselves as medicines. They are categorized as ‘food supplements’ and are not
governed by the same regulatory board that governs medicine. The packaging is
not permitted to state that the oils are “intended to diagnose, treat, cure or
prevent any disease.”
Unfortunately many eager proponents of essential oils speak
about them as though they were some new miracle cure, but this is highly
problematic considering that they are not tested for effectiveness in clinical
trials or for safety in the same way that normal medicines are.
When a product is touted to be a cure for an illness but
that product is not classified as a medicine, and when manufacturers are not
held accountable in the same way that regular medicine producers are it removes
all reasonable accountability.
To make rave claims about the medical benefits of a product
before the long-term effectiveness and safety of the remedy has been medically
verified is irresponsible and yet this often happens with essential oils.
Effectiveness
The perceived effectiveness of many essential oils is based
mostly on testimonials from those who use it. The scientific research done is
very inconclusive
.
One complicating factor in assessing their effectiveness is the placebo effect
– if you use a product after many rave reviews from friends you may experience
benefits purely as a psychosomatic effect.
Because these products are not prescribed or regulated by a
medical professional there is also the risk of harmful side-effects. Some of
their harmful side-effects are widely known, others are still being discovered.
The ‘miracle cure’
As with many alternative health products, essential oils
have developed something of a ‘cult following’. This is where Christians must
be very careful because it reveals where our faith is at.
When we become disillusioned with ‘orthodox’ medicine and
doctors we must remind ourselves that our faith is not in doctors in the first
place. While God may use medicine to heal us, God is our healer and he is the
only miracle worker.
Unfortunately, what some people do when they become
disillusioned with orthodox medicine is that they turn to alternative medicine
looking for a miracle there. But this is simply replacing one idol with
another, instead, we should examine our faith and place it firmly back on
Christ.
Pyramid schemes
Essential oils are big business. One of the ways in which
sales are made is through ‘multi-level-marketing’
which simply means that ordinary moms can become distributors from home.
The way that some essential oil sales are structured is that
you make money from sales and even more money by recruiting others to becomes
salesmen and getting commission from their sales.
Distributors are then encouraged to take make use of their
social circles as potential sales opportunities. Social media inevitably
becomes a big part of advertising to social networks.
As Christians we would be well-advised to be cautious about
becoming distributors who use our social networks in church to peddle these
products.
Anti-Western
sentiments
‘Alternative medicine’ often fosters an unhealthy cynicism
toward Western thought and particularly Western medicine.
There is cause for scepticism of ‘big Pharma’ and its
inherently money-driven agenda with its history of sometimes neglecting the
best interests of the sick to generate more income. But this scepticism should
not be exaggerated to the point of paranoia.
We must be aware that Eastern medicine and its practitioners
have their own agenda in fostering anti-Western ideas which are based on their
antagonism toward the Judeo-Christian foundations of Western thinking, and
therefore modern medicine.
Last thoughts
Herbal remedies are not evil, which is why I have taken care
not to demonize anything presenting itself as ‘alternative health’. Having said
that, I do discern some unhealthy signs coming from the contemporary alternative
health scene which I have tried to highlight in this article. Christians are
not immune to these dangers and so we must make sure that we are aware of them
and that we shine something different to the world.
References:
H. J. Bopp, Homeopathy, Down, North Ireland: Word of Life
Publications, 1984